Every tax season, the same story quietly repeats itself.
Someone flips a house.
The flip goes well.
The numbers look clean.
The profit feels earned.
Then the tax bill shows up like a jump scare.
Let’s talk about our House Flipper, Amir.
A Flip That Went Exactly Right — Until It Didn’t
Amir did everything right by internet standards.
He bought a neglected townhouse below market value.
He put in sweat equity.
He didn’t over-renovate.
He listed at the right time.
He sold fast.
After closing costs and the dust settling, he cleared about $50,000.
That’s a textbook win. Most people never even get that far.
Then tax season arrived.
His accountant went quiet for a second — which is never a good sign — and said the sentence that ruins first-time flippers:
“You didn’t structure this as a business.”
By the end of the conversation, Amir owed roughly $21,000 in taxes.
Not penalties.
Not mistakes.
Just… taxes.
Almost half his profit vanished. Not because the flip failed — but because he didn’t understand how flips are taxed.
And here’s the part that hurts:
Experienced flippers doing nearly identical deals routinely keep far more of that same $50,000.
Same market.
Same property type.
Same renovation quality.
Different tax structure.
The Core Misunderstanding That Destroys Flipping Profits
Most new flippers assume one thing — and that single assumption does catastrophic damage:
“This is a capital gain.”
Sometimes it is.
Often, it absolutely is not.
Investor vs. Dealer: The Line That Changes Everything
The IRS makes a sharp distinction between two types of people who sell property:
Investors
People who buy property primarily to hold it and generate appreciation or rental income.
Dealers
People who buy property primarily to resell it for profit.
House flippers almost always fall into the dealer category.
Intent matters. A lot.
If you buy a property planning to sell it quickly, renovate it, market it, and move on — congratulations, you’re running a business in the eyes of the IRS.
That means your profit is ordinary business income, not capital gains.
And that’s where the tax pain begins.
Why “Ordinary Income” Is So Much Worse Than Capital Gains
Capital gains get special treatment. Business income does not.
When flip profit is treated as ordinary income, several things happen at once:
• Your profit is taxed at your marginal income tax rate
• Self-employment tax applies (Social Security + Medicare)
• State income tax stacks on top
In real terms, that can mean:
• Up to 37% federal income tax
• 15.3% self-employment tax
• Plus state taxes
That’s how people lose “40%” of a flip without ever realizing where it went.
The IRS isn’t being cruel. It’s applying business tax rules to people who accidentally ran a business without realizing it.
Professionals know this.
Beginners learn it the hard way.
Why Professional Flippers Always Treat Flips Like a Business
Seasoned flippers don’t casually report flip income and hope for mercy.
They structure before the deal closes.
Most operate through formal business entities such as:
• LLCs
• S-Corporations
• Partnerships
This isn’t paperwork theater. Structure determines how income is taxed — and how much of it escapes self-employment tax.
Why S-Corps Are So Popular Among Flippers
For repeat or full-time flippers, S-Corporations are especially common for one reason:
They allow income splitting.
Here’s how it works in plain English:
Instead of all profit being treated as self-employment income, you pay yourself a reasonable salary, and the rest comes out as distributions.
You pay payroll taxes only on the salary portion.
Distributions are not subject to self-employment tax.
Example:
A flip generates $100,000 in profit.
• You pay yourself a salary of $50,000
• Payroll taxes apply to that $50,000
• The remaining $50,000 comes out as distributions
That single structural choice can save thousands of dollars per year, completely legally.
This is not a loophole. It’s how the tax code is written.
Cost Basis: Where the Real Tax Savings Actually Live
Most people think tax savings come from deductions.
They help — but the biggest lever in flipping is cost basis.
Your taxable profit is calculated as:
Sale price – total cost basis
The higher your basis, the lower your taxable gain.
Professional flippers treat basis tracking like a competitive sport.
New flippers… guess.
What Professionals Add to Basis (and Beginners Forget)
A proper flip basis includes far more than purchase price and lumber receipts.
Common basis items include:
• Purchase price
• Closing costs
• Title and escrow fees
• Rehab materials
• Contractor labor
• Permits
• Inspections
• Appraisals
• Dumpster rentals
• Utilities during renovation
• Insurance while under construction
• Equipment rentals
• Tools used exclusively for the project
• Mileage tied to the property
Miss half of these, and your “profit” inflates on paper — which means higher taxes for no reason.
It’s incredibly common for a flip that looks like a $60,000 profit to drop below $20,000 in taxable income once everything is properly documented.
Deducted vs. Capitalized: Where People Get Confused
Not all costs are treated the same way.
Some increase your basis.
Others reduce taxable income immediately.
Understanding the difference is where professionals quietly dominate.
Costs Typically Added to Basis
These reduce your gain when the property sells:
• Structural improvements
• Roofing
• Flooring
• Electrical upgrades
• Plumbing
• Additions or layout changes
Costs Often Deducted as Business Expenses
These reduce taxable income in the year they occur:
• Tools
• Accounting software
• Bookkeeping services
• Marketing
• Phone and internet (business portion)
• Home office expenses
• Mileage
• Insurance
• Professional fees
Professionals maximize both categories.
Beginners usually miss both.
Safe Harbor Rules: The IRS Gift Most Flippers Never Open
The tax code contains “safe harbor” provisions that allow certain costs to be deducted immediately instead of capitalized.
Two matter a lot for flippers.
The De Minimis Safe Harbor
Items under $2,500 per invoice can often be expensed immediately.
This includes:
• Appliances
• Fixtures
• Hardware
• Tools
• Small equipment
Many flippers capitalize these unnecessarily, delaying deductions they could have taken the same year.
Routine Maintenance Safe Harbor
If you reasonably expect a repair to occur more than once over a property’s life, it may qualify as deductible maintenance.
Things like:
• Minor HVAC servicing
• Small repairs
• Routine upkeep
During active flipping years, this rule alone can reduce taxable income significantly.
Could Holding for One Year Change Everything?
Sometimes, yes.
If a property is not treated as dealer inventory, holding it for over 12 months may allow long-term capital gains treatment.
That means tax rates of:
• 0%
• 15%
• 20%
Instead of ordinary income plus self-employment tax.
This usually requires:
• Fewer flips
• No aggressive marketing during rehab
• Possibly renting the property first
• Clear intent to invest rather than flip
When done correctly, the difference between a 40% tax hit and a 15% tax hit is life-changing.
This is why some professionals deliberately slow down — not because they can’t flip faster, but because the math works better.
Same Deal, Wildly Different Outcomes
Let’s compare two flippers.
Same house.
Same numbers.
Same market.
Beginner outcome:
• Missed expenses
• No entity structure
• Ordinary income taxation
• No safe harbor usage
Effective tax hit: ~$19,500
Professional outcome:
• Every cost tracked
• S-Corp structure
• Salary + distribution split
• Safe harbor deductions applied
Effective tax hit: ~$7,800
Same deal.
Nearly $12,000 difference.
That’s not luck.
That’s tax literacy.
The Real Lesson: Flipping Is Not Casual Income
House flipping isn’t a side hustle the IRS ignores.
It’s a business with rules.
The flippers who win long-term don’t dodge taxes. They understand them.
They structure early.
They document obsessively.
They use the tax code exactly as written.
Making money on a flip feels great.
Keeping it is the real skill.
If you want to see what your own flip might look like after taxes — or compare structures, holding periods, and timing strategies — you can run the numbers anytime at:
Because profit is exciting.
But after-tax profit is what actually builds wealth.
Leave a Reply